Shared ground
Matthew presents Jesus’ entry as a public procession, not a private arrival. The crowd actively “makes a way” for him by spreading garments and branches on the road. Their loud, repeated cries make the moment city-facing and impossible to ignore.
The shouts combine honor-language and prayer-language. “Hosanna” functions as a cry asking for help and also as praise. Calling Jesus “Son of David” treats him as a figure connected to Israel’s royal hope, and blessing the one who comes “in the name of the Lord” frames the moment in worshipful terms.
The city’s reaction shows a gap between the procession and Jerusalem as a whole. The question “Who is this?” implies that many in the city do not yet have a settled view of Jesus.
The crowd’s answer (“the prophet…from Nazareth of Galilee”) both elevates Jesus and locates him. They identify him with prophetic authority while also stressing his known origin outside Jerusalem.
Where interpretation differs
Some readers take the crowd’s words (“Son of David,” “Hosanna”) as a clear, mainly messianic and kingly claim, even if not everyone grasped its full meaning. Others think the language could be sincere but still mixed with unclear expectations—honoring Jesus intensely without a precise understanding of what kind of leader he is.
Some read “This is the prophet” as a lesser title than “Son of David,” suggesting the crowd may be backpedaling or offering a safer description for the wider city. Others read it as complementary: Jesus is both a royal heir and a prophet, and the crowd answers the city with a category many could recognize.
Why the disagreement exists
The passage itself juxtaposes titles: highly charged acclamation in v.9 and a more descriptive identification in v.11. It also reports two audiences (the moving crowd and “all the city”) and two responses (praise and questioning). That structure leaves room for different judgments about how coherent the crowd’s understanding was.
What this passage clearly contributes
Explicitly, the text shows Jesus entering Jerusalem amid mass public honor, framed in God-focused language (“in the name of the Lord”), and causing city-wide disturbance and inquiry. It contributes to Matthew’s portrait of Jesus as publicly significant and contested: celebrated by many, questioned by others, and identified in ways that both raise expectations (“Son of David”) and underline his surprising background (“Nazareth of Galilee”). See also Matthew 21:1 for the deliberate setup of the entry.