Shared ground
These verses present God as personally involved in the speaker’s origin. The language of “formed” and “knit” portrays intentional craftsmanship, not a distant or accidental beginning. The speaker’s response is gratitude and awe: his existence is “fearfully and wonderfully made,” and he regards God’s work as excellent.
The passage also stresses God’s perfect awareness in hidden places. Even when the speaker was “made in secret,” God still saw his “frame,” including his earliest, “unformed” stage (). The images (“woven,” “depths of the earth,” “book”) communicate concealment from human sight but not from God.
Where interpretation differs
Some readers take “in your book they were all written…the days…ordained” to mean a fixed, detailed plan for the entire life, including the timing and content of each day. Others read it as poetic confidence that God already had the speaker’s life in view and under care before it began, without specifying how much is settled versus open.
Another smaller difference is how to handle the imagery of being “woven…in the depths of the earth.” Many take it as a metaphor for the womb as a hidden place; a few explore whether it echoes broader ancient “from the earth” creation language. In either case, the point remains God’s knowledge and involvement during unseen development.
Why the disagreement exists
The text is poetic and uses pictures (“knit,” “woven,” “book”) rather than technical description. Because “days…ordained” can sound like a schedule and “book” can sound like a record, readers differ on how tightly to connect the image to a full statement about the future.
What this passage clearly contributes
Explicitly, it teaches that God is credited as the maker of the speaker’s inner life and body from the womb, that God’s work is worthy of awe, and that God sees a person even at the earliest, unformed stage. It also clearly links God’s knowledge of a person (139:1–12) to God’s involvement before birth: divine knowledge is not merely observation after the fact but reaches back to beginnings and encompasses the span of one’s “days,” however the “book” image is understood.