Shared ground
These verses describe an inner “fullness” that the speaker compares to the richest food. The text presents this as something the speaker expects to experience (“my soul shall be satisfied”), and it immediately connects that satisfaction to outward speech: joyful praise (v. 5). That link—inner satisfaction leading to verbal praise—is explicit.
The setting is the night. The speaker remembers God while on the bed and keeps thinking about him during the “night watches” (v. 6). The reason given for this nighttime joy is also explicit: God “has been my help” in the past (v. 7). The final image (“shadow of your wings”) communicates protection and safety, using concrete language for a relational reality.
Where interpretation differs
1) Is the satisfaction present, or confidently expected?
Some read v. 5 as describing a current experience of fullness in God that the speaker already feels, especially since it flows straight into praise. Others read it as future-oriented confidence (“will be satisfied”), fitting a psalm that moves from need to settled assurance.
2) Is the “rich food” language about worship at a sanctuary, or only a metaphor?
Some hear echoes of formal worship and feasting language and think the speaker is longing to return to public worship where rich portions were known. Others think the point is simply metaphor: even in scarcity or danger, God can satisfy as fully as a feast.
3) What exactly are the “night watches,” and what do the “wings” point to?
Some take “night watches” as literal periods of being awake (because of threat, travel, guard duty, or sleeplessness). Others treat it as poetic shorthand for “all night.” Likewise, “wings” can be read as general protection language, or as protection associated with God’s presence in worship space. Either way, the immediate meaning in the verse is safety under God’s care.
Why the disagreement exists
The Hebrew poetry compresses experience into images: rich food, nighttime hours, wings. Those images can point both to ordinary life (hunger, wakefulness, vulnerability) and to worship-associated memory (feast language and protection imagery). Also, English future-sounding phrasing (“shall be”) can represent either present confidence or future expectation, depending on context.
What this passage clearly contributes
The passage ties together three claims: (1) God can satisfy the inner person more deeply than physical abundance (v. 5); (2) remembering and thinking about God can fill vulnerable nighttime hours with stable joy (v. 6); and (3) past experiences of God’s help provide a rational basis for present rejoicing and a sense of protection (v. 7). The text does not spell out the mechanism of how satisfaction comes; it presents the speaker’s testimony and resulting praise as the main point. See also the broader biblical theme of God as giver of satisfaction and refuge (e.g., Psalm 36:8).