Shared ground
The text presents David’s ark project as a national act, not a small court event. It repeatedly says “all Israel,” then defines the scale by naming the far southern and far northern edges. Explicitly, the purpose of the gathering is to bring the ark of God from Kiriath-jearim.
The destination in v. 6 is described with two names: Baalah “that is” Kiriath-jearim, and the location is linked to Judah. The ark is described with elevated language: it belongs to “God, the LORD,” is connected with God’s enthronement “above the cherubim,” and is tied to “the Name,” signaling recognized divine presence and authority rather than a mere national artifact.
Where interpretation differs
How literal “all Israel” is. Some read it as nearly everyone being present; others read it as a formal national assembly led by representatives (leaders, warriors, or tribal heads). The text itself stresses breadth and unity, but does not list who attended.
How to map the geography. Readers differ on what “Shihor of Egypt” refers to (a Nile-related branch vs. a border stream near Egypt) and how exact “the entrance of Hamath” is as a boundary marker. In either case, the point is a nation-wide span.
How Baalah relates to Kiriath-jearim. Many take Baalah as another name for the same town; others think it may be a nearby site or district label associated with Kiriath-jearim. The verse’s own wording presses toward close identification.
What “called by the Name” means. Some take it to mean the ark is officially marked as belonging to the LORD (bearing his Name); others connect it to the idea that God’s Name is invoked there in worship and covenant allegiance. The wording clearly links the ark to God’s public identity.
Why the disagreement exists
The passage uses traditional boundary phrases and place names that can be hard to pinpoint on a modern map. It also uses compressed, honorific wording about the ark (“enthroned above the cherubim,” “called by the Name”) without explaining the mechanics. Finally, “all Israel” is a common biblical way of describing corporate action that can be either literal or representative depending on context.
What this passage clearly contributes
This scene frames the ark’s relocation as a unifying national event under David’s leadership (explicit in the repeated “David… and all Israel”). It highlights that the ark is not simply a royal possession but is bound to the LORD’s identity and kingship language (“enthroned above the cherubim”). It also signals that Israel’s political consolidation is being tied to a shared religious center, anticipating the worship-focused direction of the surrounding narrative and the parallel account in 2 Samuel 6:1–2.