Shared ground
Paul explains Christ’s work as something believers share in because they are united with him (repeatedly: “with him”). The passage stacks images to say a decisive change has already happened: a deep “cutting off” (circumcision language), a death-and-new-life transition (burial and resurrection language tied to baptism), complete forgiveness, and the removal of something that stood against “us.”
Several claims are explicit in the wording: believers were “circumcised” in a way “not made with hands,” they were “buried with him in baptism” and “raised with him,” they were previously dead in trespasses, God made them alive together with Christ, and God forgave “all” trespasses. The final image presents rulers and authorities as defeated and publicly exposed.
Where interpretation differs
-
“The circumcision of Christ” (v.11). Some read it mainly as Christ’s own circumcision (the physical rite Jesus received), now reinterpreted as the basis of belonging. Others read it as circumcision accomplished by Christ—a spiritual removal that happens in union with him.
-
“Putting off the body of the flesh” (v.11). Some take this as primarily moral change (old sinful patterns being stripped away). Others take it as a change of status/identity—leaving behind an “old realm” described by “flesh,” without claiming instant moral perfection.
-
How baptism relates to the change (v.12). Some understand baptism here mainly as the visible sign that points to burial/raising with Christ. Others think Paul is describing baptism as the moment believers participate in that transition, while still stressing that the effective power is God’s and is received “through faith.”
-
What the “bond written in ordinances” is (vv.14–15). Some understand it as the Mosaic law’s decrees standing as a witness against sinners. Others read it more broadly as a record of debts/charges—any authoritative list of obligations that condemns “us.”
Why the disagreement exists
Paul compresses several metaphors (circumcision, baptism, a canceled record, a victory parade) without pausing to define each one. Key phrases can point in more than one direction (“circumcision of Christ,” “body of flesh,” “bond written in ordinances”), and the paragraph moves between “you” and “us,” inviting readers to ask whether the focus is on Israel’s law, human sin-debt generally, or both.
What this passage clearly contributes
This text grounds the later claim that believers do not need extra markers or mediators (Colossians 2:16): in Christ, the core problem (death in trespasses) is answered (made alive with him), the core barrier (a condemning record) is removed (wiped out and nailed to the cross), and hostile powers are shown to be defeated. The logic is union-focused: what is true of Christ (death-to-life, victory) is shared by those connected to him.