Shared ground
Genesis 5:21–24 presents Enoch inside a genealogy that usually ends with a blunt report of death. Enoch’s entry follows the normal pattern at first: his age at the birth of a named son (Methuselah), the years that follow, more children, and a total lifespan. But it then draws attention to something else: twice it says Enoch “walked with God,” and it replaces the expected “and he died” with “he was not, for God took him.”
The passage explicitly claims (1) Enoch fathered Methuselah at 65, (2) afterward he “walked with God” for 300 years while also having other children, (3) his total years were 365, and (4) he “was not” because God “took him.” Any further explanation about how and where he went is inference beyond what is directly said.
Where interpretation differs
The main difference is what “God took him” means in ordinary narrative terms.
Some understand it as God removing Enoch from earthly life without death (a translation into God’s presence). On this reading, “he was not” means people could no longer find him among the living because God directly relocated him.
Others understand it as a special way of describing Enoch’s death: he was removed from life by God, but the text chooses not to say “he died” because it wants to highlight Enoch’s relationship with God rather than the fact of death.
A smaller difference shows up in “walked with God.” Many take it as a summary of faithful, steady fellowship and obedience over time. Others read it more narrowly as a public reputation for piety or a life aligned with God’s will, without specifying the details.
Why the disagreement exists
The wording is brief and unusual. “He was not” is a compressed expression that states absence without describing the event. “God took him” makes God the direct actor, but it does not spell out whether this “taking” is a rescue from death, an alternative to death, or a death described from God’s side. The genealogy’s repeated rhythm (“and he died”) creates pressure to explain why Enoch’s entry breaks that pattern.
What this passage clearly contributes
It highlights that, even in a list focused on ancestry and mortality, a person’s life can be summarized by relationship and direction (“walked with God”), not only by years and offspring. It also introduces an exceptional ending within Adam’s line: Enoch’s departure is attributed directly to God and is narrated differently from the others, marking him as distinct within the genealogy (Genesis 5:21–Genesis 5:24).