Shared ground
Isaiah 59:5–8 uses vivid pictures to say that certain people’s plans and patterns reliably produce harm. What they “make” is compared to deadly snake eggs and to spider webs: one image stresses danger, the other stresses uselessness as protection. The passage then shifts from “products” to “paths,” describing speed toward wrongdoing, innocent bloodshed, and a social landscape marked by ruin.
The text’s explicit claims are about what “they” do and what follows: their deeds are called “iniquity” (iniquity), violence is “in their hands,” and their way of life does not include “peace” or “justice.”
Where interpretation differs
Who “they” are. Some read “they” mainly as leaders and power-brokers (judges, officials, influential people) because the chapter focuses on public breakdown and justice. Others read it more broadly as the community at large, since the language can cover shared social habits, not only official actions.
What “crooked paths” refers to. Some take it chiefly as individual moral choices (personal conduct that harms others). Others emphasize wider social patterns (systems and routines that make harm normal and peace hard to find). Many readings combine both: personal choices that build unjust social pathways.
What it means to “not know” peace. Some treat “not know” (shall know) as lacking experience of peace because their practices destroy it. Others stress refusal: they do not recognize or accept peace as the right road.
Why the disagreement exists
The passage blends metaphor (“eggs,” “webs,” “paths”) with direct moral description (“violence,” “shed innocent blood”). That mix leaves open whether Isaiah’s main target is a specific class of wrongdoers, the whole society, or both, and whether “paths” are mainly personal behavior, public policy, or the shared moral infrastructure of daily life.
What this passage clearly contributes
This unit portrays wrongdoing as productive: it generates further danger even when confronted (“crushing” still releases threat), and it fails to provide real covering or security (webs cannot become garments). It also portrays evil as directional: people’s “feet” and “goings” form routes where justice is absent and peace is unknown. The theological inference is that injustice is not only a set of isolated acts but a practiced way of life that shapes a community’s environment—what it creates and where it leads.