Shared ground
Psalm 11:6–7 closes with two outcomes. First, Yahweh is said to send a devastating judgment on “the wicked,” pictured as a sky-falling storm of burning materials (“blazing coals,” “fire,” “sulfur,” and “scorching wind”). Second, the reason is Yahweh’s character: he is righteous and he righteousness. On that basis, “the upright” are promised nearness to him, described as “seeing his face.”
The passage is explicit that the outcomes are not random; they are tied to what God is like (righteous) and what God values (righteousness). The language of “cup” frames the wicked’s outcome as an assigned share or allotted experience.
Where interpretation differs
How “literal” the judgment imagery is. Some read the fire-and-sulfur storm mainly as poetic speech for catastrophic ruin that God brings on the wicked (without specifying the mechanism). Others think it may echo real historical judgments (or patterns of judgment) and so leans closer to a literal picture of divine destruction.
What “the portion of their cup” emphasizes. Some take “cup” primarily as a measured allotment—judgment that is fitting and not accidental. Others hear “cup” as broader destiny-language: the wicked’s chosen path ends in a bitter assigned outcome.
What “see his face” refers to. Some interpret it mainly as access and acceptance in worship (temple/court imagery: being granted audience). Others take it as a more direct encounter with God’s presence, still expressed in relational terms (welcome rather than exclusion).
Why the disagreement exists
The psalm uses dense metaphor (storm/fire/cup/face) rather than explaining the mechanics. Those images had recognized social and worship meanings in ancient settings (allotted “cup,” access to a superior’s “face”), but they can also be heard as speaking beyond any single setting.
What this passage clearly contributes
It contributes a tight logic: (1) God acts against wickedness (v.6), (2) because God is righteous and favors what is right (v.7a), therefore (3) the upright are not abandoned but are brought near (“see his face,” v.7b). The closing reassurance is relational, not merely the avoidance of disaster: the end point for the upright is access to God’s favorable presence (compare the theme of desiring God’s face in Psalm 27:8).