Shared ground
Psalm 58:3–5 uses stacked images to argue that “the wicked” in view are not merely making occasional mistakes; they are deeply set in a pattern of harmful deceit. The text explicitly claims they “go astray from the womb,” are “wayward as soon as born,” and are marked by “speaking lies” from the start. It then compares their harmfulness to snake venom (a picture of danger that spreads and injures), and to a “deaf cobra” that will not respond even to skilled charmers.
A theological inference (beyond the explicit wording) is that some forms of evil become so entrenched that ordinary social tools—reasoning, correction, pressure, even expertise—fail to restrain it. The passage also assumes moral accountability: the problem is not ignorance but a settled refusal to be turned.
Where interpretation differs (only where needed)
One difference is how literally to take “from the womb / as soon as born.” Some read it as a direct claim about inborn corruption: humans can be bent toward wrongdoing from the earliest point of life. Others read it as poetic exaggeration meant to stress just how long-standing and habitual these people’s deception is, without making a biological claim about infants.
A second difference is what “speaking lies” and “venom” most directly refer to. Some hear courtroom and leadership settings in the background (lies that function like poison in public justice). Others take it more broadly as deceitful speech in general, with “venom” covering the whole harmful output of their lives (words, intentions, and resulting actions).
A third difference is how the “deaf cobra” works as a metaphor. Some emphasize deliberate stubbornness (“stops its ear” as chosen resistance). Others hear a stronger sense of fixed character—people who have become effectively unreachable.
Why the disagreement exists
The language is poetic and metaphor-heavy: birth imagery (“from the womb”), animal venom, and snake-handling scenes are not clinical descriptions. Because metaphors compress meaning, readers must decide how much is literal claim versus rhetorical force. Also, the psalm’s larger setting (a protest against corrupt leaders) makes it plausible that the “lies” are public and judicial, but the verses themselves do not limit the referent.
What this passage clearly contributes
This passage contributes a concentrated portrait of hardened wickedness: (1) long-established deviation (“from the womb”), (2) deceit as a defining feature (“speaking lies”), (3) harm that spreads like poison (“venom”), and (4) resistance to restraint (“deaf cobra” that ignores even skilled charmers). It sets up the psalm’s later urgency by arguing that the problem is not minor error but entrenched, dangerous, and unresponsive wrongdoing (cf. Psalm 58:1 for the leadership/justice frame).