Skip to content

    Jeremiah 4:19-22

    Personal anguish and the charge of folly

    Read the passage

    Loading your study tools…

    Historical commentary

    Return to reading
    • Adam Clarke's Commentary and critical notes on the Bible - Jeremiah (book-scoped electronic witness)

      Adam Clarke, Commentary and critical notes on the Bible; CrossWire Clarke module 2.0 (2021-10-19), Wikisource-derived electronic text. CrossWire identifies this distribution as Public Domain. Underlying print manifestation unidentified.

      CrossWire Clarke module 2.0 (2021-10-19); exact digital manifestation; underlying print edition unidentified.

      Source reading — literal projection of the electronic edition

      Read source: Adam Clarke's Commentary and critical notes on the Bible - Jeremiah (book-scoped electronic witness)
    • Adam Clarke's Commentary and critical notes on the Bible - Jeremiah (book-scoped electronic witness)

      Adam Clarke, Commentary and critical notes on the Bible; CrossWire Clarke module 2.0 (2021-10-19), Wikisource-derived electronic text. CrossWire identifies this distribution as Public Domain. Underlying print manifestation unidentified.

      CrossWire Clarke module 2.0 (2021-10-19); exact digital manifestation; underlying print edition unidentified.

      Source reading — literal projection of the electronic edition

      Read source: Adam Clarke's Commentary and critical notes on the Bible - Jeremiah (book-scoped electronic witness)

    Adam Clarke's Commentary and critical notes on the Bible - Jeremiah (book-scoped electronic witness)

    Adam Clarke, Commentary and critical notes on the Bible; CrossWire Clarke module 2.0 (2021-10-19), Wikisource-derived electronic text. CrossWire identifies this distribution as Public Domain. Underlying print manifestation unidentified.

    Citation details
    Author
    Adam Clarke
    Work
    Adam Clarke's Commentary and critical notes on the Bible
    Language
    en
    Archive reference
    https://www.crosswire.org/ftpmirror/pub/sword/packages/rawzip/Clarke.zip

    Source representation

    Source reading — literal projection of the electronic edition

    Normalization only. Raw source unavailable; raw-source authority is not presented.

    Source reading

    Adam Clarke, Commentary and critical notes on the Bible; CrossWire Clarke module 2.0 (2021-10-19), Wikisource-derived electronic text. CrossWire identifies this distribution as Public Domain. Underlying print manifestation unidentified.

    CrossWire Clarke module 2.0 (2021-10-19); exact digital manifestation; underlying print edition unidentified.

    Verse 19 My bowels - From this to the twenty-ninth verse the prophet describes the ruin of Jerusalem and the desolation of Judea by the Chaldeans in language and imagery scarcely paralleled in the whole Bible. At the sight of misery the bowels are first affected; pain is next felt by a sort of stricture in the pericardium; and then, the heart becoming strongly affected by irregular palpitations, a gush of tears, accompanied with wailings, is the issue. - "My bowels, my bowels! I am pained at my very heart, (the walls of my heart); my heart maketh a noise in me; I cannot hold my peace." Here is nature, and fact also.

    Bible & Context editorial context

    Clarke explicitly frames verses 19–29 but keeps a verse-19 heading. His description of bowel, pericardial and heart responses is historical physiology, not a validated sequence, a diagnosis or grounds to dismiss physical symptoms as merely grief. The following biblical quotation and his own bodily explanation remain separate. Do not force the lament's intensity into a clinical or moral label.

    Historical commentary composite, not all source words Clarke speech or canonical quotation

    Clarke literary evaluation

    Clarke historical physiology

    Prophetic lament as incorporated

    Alternatives

    1. The speaker and imagery may express profound distress without specifying its mechanism or guaranteeing a single bodily response.

    Literal source scope

    Not established in the stored profile.

    Paragraph anchor
    Not established
    Source section range
    Not established

    Reviewed subject scope

    Reviewed subject, not a literal source heading or source range.

    Anchor
    Jer.4.19
    Subject start
    Jer.4.19
    Subject end
    Jer.4.29

      Canonical attachment

      Not the complete owner range or a literal source heading.

      Reference
      /jeremiah/4/19-22
      Reviewed paragraph anchor
      Jer.4.19