Shared ground
Matthew presents the empty tomb as a public, observable event framed by divine action. Two known women go to the tomb at first light after the Sabbath, and what they encounter is not just an open grave but an interpreted message: Jesus “is not here” because “he has been raised” (Matthew 28:6). The angel’s role is to explain what the empty tomb means and to direct the flow of the story toward the disciples and a future meeting in Galilee.
The narrative also highlights contrast: guards posted to secure the tomb are overwhelmed by fear and become powerless, while the women receive clarity and instruction. The stone is moved, the guards react, and the women are invited to look and then to carry a message.
Where interpretation differs
Some readers take the earthquake and angelic descent as happening right as the women arrive. Others think Matthew is summarizing what happened earlier at the tomb, with the women arriving after the stone has already been moved, and the story is told in a way that lets the reader “see” it.
There is also a difference in how people picture the guards “became like dead men” (v. 4). Some read it as fainting; others as being rigid with fear or collapsing in shock. The basic point in the text is their inability to act.
Finally, some emphasize that the stone was moved so Jesus could exit the tomb. Others emphasize that it was moved so witnesses could see that the tomb was already empty.
Why the disagreement exists
Matthew uses vivid, compressed storytelling (“behold,” the earthquake, the angel sitting on the stone) that does not pause to spell out timing details. The phrase “became like dead men” is also a strong image that describes an effect (helplessness) more than a medical diagnosis. And the passage says the angel rolled the stone away, but it does not directly explain whether that act was for Jesus’ release or for human verification.
What this passage clearly contributes
Explicitly, the passage asserts: the women came; an angel descended; the stone was rolled away; the guards were terrified into helplessness; the angel told the women not to fear; Jesus is not in the tomb because he has been raised; the women are invited to look at the place where he was lying; and they are to tell the disciples that Jesus is risen and will be seen in Galilee (vv. 1–7).
By implication, Matthew frames the resurrection announcement as both grounded in a physical location (“see the place”) and tied to Jesus’ prior words (“just as he said”). The scene also sets up Galilee as the next major location for confirming encounters and continuing the story.