Shared ground
Obadiah 1:15–16 presents “the day of Yahweh” as imminent (“near”) and aimed not only at Edom but at all nations. The text’s explicit claim is that Yahweh’s coming “day” brings a moral reversal: what nations have done will come back on them, pictured as their deeds returning “on your own head.”
The passage also uses a repeated image of “drinking” that intensifies (“drink… swallow down”) and ends with an undoing so complete it is described as becoming “as though they had not been.” Whatever the “drinking” signifies, it is tied to Yahweh’s “holy mountain” and communicates decisive reversal and collapse.
Where interpretation differs
Who the “you” is in v.16. Some readings treat the “you” as Edom (continuing the earlier address), with “all the nations” then broadened as the main point. Other readings treat the “you” more broadly as the group of nations implicated in Jerusalem’s downfall, with Edom as the lead example.
What the “drinking” image means. Some take it as hostile celebration or gloating connected to Jerusalem’s disaster (a kind of triumphing on Yahweh’s mountain). Others take it as forced drinking as an image for receiving overwhelming judgment (like being made to drink a bitter cup). Both approaches agree the image signals reversal and ends in ruin.
How final “as though they had not been” is. Some understand it as literal disappearance of peoples. Others read it as political or historical vanishing—collapse of power, identity, and presence—without requiring the claim that every person is physically wiped out.
Why the disagreement exists
The text is short and poetic, and it does not explain its metaphors. The “drinking” language can be used in more than one way in the prophets, and the reference to “my holy mountain” could point either to a past act of profaning/celebrating there or to the mountain as the place from which Yahweh’s judgment is measured. Also, “as though they had not been” is an intentionally extreme line that could be read as either literal extinction or rhetorical emphasis.
What this passage clearly contributes
- It pushes the scope from a local conflict (Edom and Judah) to a wider claim: Yahweh’s “day” reaches all nations.
- It states a clear moral logic in plain terms: actions return to the actor (“as you have done… your deeds will return”).
- It depicts judgment as escalating and overwhelming (drink → swallow down → vanish), emphasizing the completeness of the reversal.
- It ties the nations’ fate to what happened “on my holy mountain,” suggesting that treatment of Yahweh’s people and place is not merely political but accountable to Yahweh’s rule (Obadiah 1:15–16).